Tropical Food Forests

I Lost Hundreds of Fruit Trees

How planting without a system taught me what tropical regrowth can do to young trees

By Neema Naeemi · · 4 min read

When I first started planting fruit trees, I was excited enough to scatter them across the property. My intention was to follow nature: seeds fall, trees emerge, and eventually a forest forms.

But that process works differently in a mature system, where an overhead canopy of pioneer species creates enough shade to keep aggressive ground vegetation from overwhelming young trees.

Growth in the tropics is abundant and ferocious. Leave land alone for five or ten years, and much of it can naturally return to forest. We talk about reforestation as though nature needs us to direct the process. Often, the moment we step back, she begins to reforest herself. But establishing a lasting, edible, perennial food forest is humbling. In the tropics and subtropics, the speed of that natural growth can also make our work much more challenging.

Pioneer tree species arrive and create shade. Birds return and spread seeds. Trees that grow beneath the canopy begin to rise. That process is quite different from the planting conditions many of us are familiar with.

I hadn't accounted for the difference between that established forest and the young trees I was putting into open land.

The property still needed regular chop-and-drop clearing, so I asked my workers to do it. They had to move through all that vegetation and somehow find the fruit trees I'd planted. Many were lost. Hundreds, in fact.

The biggest problem was organizational. I hadn't fully understood what maintaining those plantings would require. With so much work on a new property, I want to do things properly the first time rather than repeatedly undoing and rebuilding them.

WHAT THE FIRST WET SEASON TEACHES YOU

When you buy a large piece of land, the seller will often cut back the vegetation so you can see the property clearly, unless you're specifically buying forested land.

Then the first wet season arrives, and the land can become almost unrecognizable beneath the new growth. That regrowth is natural, but it changes the maintenance work dramatically.

If your plan is to keep the entire property cleared through the growing season, you may find yourself returning to the same work every three to five weeks. Vegetation can quickly overtake young fruit trees.

The challenge is making sure the trees you deliberately planted don't disappear into all that growth.

THE TREES HAVE TO BE VISIBLE TO THE PEOPLE CARING FOR THEM

I used stakes to identify my trees. When the vegetation grows back, bright red flagging tape can make a planting much easier to spot.

When trees are planted along a visible line, workers can often identify the ones we're trying to preserve, even when the surrounding vegetation has grown back.

Line of sight is what I look for.

That doesn't mean we need to turn the land into a conventional orchard. We're learning from nature, and we're part of nature ourselves. But we're also human, with other responsibilities competing for our time. So we make thoughtful compromises. If planting young fruit trees within sight of one another helps us protect them until they reach a more mature height, we can make that choice while still allowing nature to scatter her seeds and the next generation to rise among the growth.

The people caring for the land need to know which trees to protect. When workers help plant them, they can also help identify them later.

In the first couple of years, land development pulls your attention in many directions. Being realistic about that workload, and deciding what deserves attention first, matters.

That's why we focus on the perimeter.

For me, that is the lesson in losing hundreds of trees. I was excited to plant them. I needed a way to protect what I'd planted.

WHAT IF YOU'VE ALREADY LOST TREES?

One thing I hear often is, “I don't have a green thumb. I'm not cut out for this. I just don't know what works.”

Losing plants you've worked hard to establish is discouraging. But that doesn't mean you're incapable of growing food. It means you may need a clearer strategy, a workable plan, and the chance to learn from what happened.

ABOUT THE BOOK

If you're buying land, or you've already started planting and the work feels scattered, I wrote So You Bought Land, Now What? to help you understand how the planting fits alongside access, water, workers, construction, and the seasons. The full book walks through the larger Year One approach.

← Back to the journal